As Santa Clara County deliberates over the use of artificial turf, stakeholders express a range of opinions and concerns regarding its environmental impact, health effects, and maintenance challenges.
In a recent session, both Supervisor Chavez and Ellenberg raised concerns about the potential ban's impact on ongoing negotiations with county land leaseholders who have or plan to install artificial turf. Although Chavez proposed excluding ongoing projects from the ban, this provision did not make it into the final vote.
While artificial turf was once hailed as a water-saving measure during California's drought, concerns have emerged regarding its actual water usage. According to Lee, artificial turf requires significant water for cleaning and cooling, nearly comparable to natural grass. Additionally, worries persist about plastic runoff and increased injury rates associated with artificial turf.
The Santa Clara County Medical Association has thrown its support behind the proposed ban, citing concerns about chemicals in artificial grass linked to cancer and excessive heat radiation. Environmental groups, including the Sierra Club Loma Prieta Chapter, have also voiced support for the ban in hopes of reducing artificial turf usage.
Susan Hinton of the Sierra Club emphasized the benefits of living plants and expressed optimism about the potential reduction in artificial turf usage.
Cortney Jansen, a member of Community For Natural Play Surfaces, sees the ban as a positive step toward promoting natural alternatives. She hopes other jurisdictions will follow suit, similar to Sunnyvale's ongoing research into a ban.
Sports representatives acknowledge the benefits of natural grass fields but lament the lack of maintenance by local jurisdictions. Sandra Todd, a board member of the Morgan Hill Outdoor Sports Center, highlighted the demand for athletic fields and the challenges natural grass faces in meeting this demand.
While athletic fields are considered a functional use of artificial turf, the county's investigation will also consider non-functional lawns, such as artificial turf in landscaping. Damon James, President of the Sunnyvale Alliance Soccer Club, expressed concerns about maintenance and sought clarity on alternative options.
The debate over artificial turf in Santa Clara County reflects a complex balance between environmental concerns, health considerations, and the practical needs of athletic organizations. As discussions continue, stakeholders advocate for solutions that prioritize sustainability and community well-being.